This all-natural brand offers eight flavors that are all manufactured in the U.S., making it a truly unique substitution. Try using this substitution to make a walnut Manhattan or for a bourbon Old Fashion. 8. Scrappy Bitters No, Peychaud’s bitters do not need to be refrigerated. They would be fine in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight and heat. But what makes Peychaud's Bitters so special? Well, it has a unique flavor profile that's both sweet and bitter, with notes of anise, cherry, and clove.

When comparing Peychaud's and Angostura bitters, the contrasting flavor profiles showcase the unique characteristics of each brand. Peychaud's bitters, known for its delicate and lighter profile, entices the palate with its sweet and aromatic notes. Anise and cherry are the two primary flavors, balanced by hints of clove, orange, and mint. The bitter finish adds complexity, balancing the sweetness and ensuring a well-rounded experience. And that bright red hue can be spotted from a mile away! I tried making a Spritz with Aperol, Luxardo Aperitivo, and Peychaud’s Aperitivo, and Peychaud’s took a solid third place — it just didn’t have enough bitterness to hold its own in the drink. (By the way: This time out, I found the Aperol version to be my favorite.) See our in-depth comparison of these two bitters brands showing the distinct characteristics of each product. Best SubstitutesAngostura Bitters are also gluten-free, making them a safe option for large parties. Like Peychaud’s Bitters, angostura relies on gentian root as a bittering agent. Peychaud bitters are based on grain alcohol infused with gentian root, aniseed, licorice, mint, saffron, citrus, and cloves. The exact composition and complete list of ingredients in Peychaud's bitters is a trade secret. If you’re familiar with Aperol or Campari, you understand the basics of the amaro/aperitivo category: bittersweet, emphasis on bitter, bright red in color, and quite low in proof. (At 11% alcohol, Peychaud’s is comparable to both of the aforementioned liqueurs.) This can be used at a 1:1 ratio with Peychaud’s but be mindful of the sweetness. If you’d like the taste to be more bitter, try a 1:2 ratio.

Like Peychaud’s, gentian root is one of the main ingredients in Hummingbird Bitters. The prominence of gentian root makes Hummingbird Bitters great for aiding digestion.

Make me a cocktail

On the other hand, Angostura bitters was created in 1824 by Dr. Johann Gottlieb Benjamin Siegert, a German doctor. These bitters were initially created as a medical tincture to help soldiers relieve stomach ailments. He crafted Angostura bitters in the Venezuelan town of Angostura, now known as Ciudad Bolívar. Yes, Peychaud’s bitters can be used in an Old Fashioned. While the classic drink traditionally calls for Angostura bitters, Peychaud’s can be used to add sweeter notes. The taste of Peychaud's bitters is very different from Angostura's. They taste much lighter and fruitier, with licorice, caramelly sweetness, and a dominant anise flavor. But the flavor profile includes more. While both Peychaud’s and Angostura are 19th century elixirs that still command the attention of drinks experts around the world, VinePair put the popular bitters to the test to find out what sets these two iconic brands apart. Origin Peychaud’s is the lighter and sweeter of the two, with notes of candied cherry, clove, orange, and a distinct bitter finish. Angostura is deeper and more savory. For Shane O’Neill, the lead bartender at Quality Eats in New York, Peychaud’s has a strong anise flavor, while Angostura “has much more of a spiced flavor, like cloves and cinnamon.” Color

The history isn’t exactly clear because his son, also named Antoine, was said to get the bitters you know and love today commercialized. Combine the rum, orange peel, cardamom pods, caraway seeds & coriander seeds in a clean canning jar. Their bitters are light and dry with strong notes of anise. It balances sweetness and acidity pretty well, making it a fantastic choice for drinks with many sweet or sour ingredients. And two of the most popular brands have been dominating the market for ages: Peychaud's and Angostura Bitters.Bitters can be made to capture the flavour of herbs, roots & spices offing a medicinal flavour, whereas other bitters are made to capture the aromas of fruits & flowers.